My Alternative to the 2019-S Enhanced Proof ASE
Let me preface my post by stating that I was not interested in purchasing the recently sold out enhanced reverse proof ASE. That said, I think the finish on the ASE is exquisite. As such it is a remarkably beautiful coin that I would be proud to own. Still, ASE’s are not among the coins I regularly collect.
However, there are a few comparisons I’d like to make between the 2019-S enhanced reverse proof ASE and the British 2019 proof 5-pound “Great Engravers” two-ounce silver coin that I now own. But first, a few words concerning my newest acquisition.
The first coin in the British “Great Engravers” series is modeled after William Wyon’s 1839 gold 5-pound, “Una and the Lion”. William Wyon is among the most talented engravers ever to live and his 1839 coin is one of the most sought after and beautiful coins in the world.
The obverse of the 1839 5-pound gold coin features the 1838 young head bust of Queen Victoria. This bust continued to be featured on British coins until 1887. Queen Victoria herself was so enamored by this portrait that she is quoted as saying to William Wyon, “You always represent me favorably.” With that assessment, I couldn’t agree more. The 2019 coin features a bust of Queen Elizabeth II designed by Jody Clark.
The allegorical reverse of this coin remastered from an original die features Una representing Queen Victoria and the Lion representing England. With her scepter, Queen Victoria is shown leading her country. The Latin legend reads, “May God Direct My Steps.” Of this design Richard Sainthill (1787-1870), a prominent antiquarian and coin collector says the following: “The design, expressive though simple, and the quietness and effect of the figure of her Majesty, of the lion, and of the draperies, have never, in my opinion, been excelled. The perfect portrait of the Queen in Una and on so reduced a scale, is truly astonishing and captivating.” Again, it is hard to disagree with this assessment.
Now for my comparisons between this coin and the 2019-S enhanced reverse proof ASE. The comparison starts with my coin weighing twice as much as the ASE. My coin measures 40mm in diameter and weighs 62.42 grams with a silver content of .999 fine silver. This makes my coin much thicker than a standard ASE which in my opinion allows for a slightly higher relief. My COA has a low serial number of 0158. My coin has a mintage that is 1/10th that of the 2019-S ASE (3000 coins). Most importantly, I purchased my coin for about 1/10th of what I could currently expect to pay if I bought a certified reverse proof 70 ASE.
To be completely fair I am a little biased because “Una and the Lion” is one of my favorite coin designs. Still, I hope that those fortunate enough to get the 2019-S ASE are as happy with their purchases as I am with mine. Gary
Comments
user_7180
Level 5
A coin with real art and design. The majesty of the Lion compared to the dullness of the SAE Eagle provides perfect example of what the US Mint designers are missing.
World_Coin_Nut
Level 5
I totally agree. I recently purchased one of these also. Unfortunately, it hasn't shown up yet. It's a wonderful design. I am looking forward to future issues in the series.
coinsbygary
Level 5
My picture does not do the coin justice. You are going to love it when you get it in the hand!
Longstrider
Level 6
I was kinds trying to get a SAE when it came out. I never really expected to get on but they still P.O.'ed me with the mints ineptitude. No more mint produced rarities. Now, it is a beautiful coin ut it is the same design as the Two Nations set with Canada, lacking the "S" mint mark. Your coin is impossible to compare to the eagle. It is stunning. So few made and such a nice size. I agree with you in that a 2 ounce coins seems to be much better struck. We won't even talk about price. It's too crazy. Well done Gary. Thanks..
user_1727
Level 4
That is a really sharp coin. Cool blog.
Well worn Copper
Level 5
Wow wow wow. What a beautiful coin. Classic reverse design. Timeless.
It's Mokie
Level 6
Gary, Thanks for sharing this absolutely stunning coin. Una and The Lion is truly a masterpiece and the "canvas" the Royal Mint uses to recreate her sounds perfect. I have actually made her my wallpaper for the foreseeable future.
Mike
Level 7
I love it. A beautiful coin and great finish. Not to mention the history. Gary your blogs I look forward to. I see them on the NGC Registry. Please keep them coming. I also agree with Sun these rarities have to stop. It disappoints collectors and makes non collectors rich. Thanks.
"SUN"
Level 6
Interesting blog! Personally I think some of the limited editions from the U.S. Mint are over rated.
coinsbygary
Level 5
I deliberately tried to be very gracious about the 2019-S enhanced reverse proof ASE in my post. But since I had no intention of ordering it, I am not experiencing the disappointment that many of my fellow collectors are. If I have any ire, it is towards the US Mint for this debacle.